Growing pains: a practical guide for primary care
Professor in Paediatric Rheumatology* Helen E Foster Donna Boyd Locum GP Sharmila Jandial arc Educational Research Fellow* * Musculoskeletal Research Group, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne
Issue 1 (Hands On Series 6) Autumn 2008
Consultations about children in general practice are very common, but are mostly about upper respiratory tract infections. Musculoskeletal problems in children are rare and most GPs see so few that their level of expertise and confidence in diagnosis is low. Added to this is the anxiety exhibited by parents faced with a distressed child, in pain, who is not sleeping and disturbing the whole household. Not surprisingly, such consultations can be stressful.
My aim in commissioning the authors to write about growing pains was to demystify the condition and increase GPs’ confidence level when dealing with these challenging patients. I also sought to increase primary care knowledge about serious musculoskeletal conditions such as juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA), ensuring that these conditions are not missed.
Louise Warburton, Medical Editor Why is it important that GPs know about growing pains?
5-year-old Anna is brought to see her GP by her mother. For the last 4 weeks Anna has been waking at night complaining of sore legs. Her mother thought this might have been related to her starting school, but she is concerned that the waking at night is still happening 1 month later. She occasionally gives Anna paracetamol and rubs her legs, which usually helps. Recently Anna has started coming into her bed on the nights when the pain is severe. Mum asks her GP if these are growing pains or something more worrying.
This short case illustrates a common scenario in primary care and raises several points to consider:
What are the key features in the clinical assessment to establish or refute the diagnosis of growing pains?
What other conditions need to be considered?
What investigations are required and when should referral be considered?
What advice can be given in terms of reassurance and management?
Musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions are one of the most common complaints in children and adolescents,
with a broad spectrum of causes including chronic rheumatic disease such as juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) and potentially life-threatening conditions such as malignancy and sepsis (Table 1). Most children with MSK complaints will present initially to their GP and the majority will not need referral to secondary care. However, it is vital that children are triaged and managed appropriately, which relies on careful clinical assessment and judicious use of investigations where indicated. Herein lies the problem. Doctors in primary care report low self-confidence in their paediatric MSK (pMSK) clinical skills
and a need for more teaching in pMSK medicine;
moreover growing pains has been identified as one of the main areas of need.
TABLE 1. Common/significant causes of musculoskeletal presentations according to age.
Infection (septic arthritis, osteomyelitis – hip, spine)
Mechanical (trauma and non-accidental injury)
Congenital/developmental problems (e.g. hip dysplasia, talipes)
Neurological disease (e.g. cerebral palsy, hereditary syndromes)
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Inflammatory muscle disease
Malignant disease (e.g. leukaemia, neuroblastoma)
Early school-aged (5–10 years)
Mechanical (trauma, overuse injuries, sport injuries)
Reactive arthritis/transient synovitis – ‘irritable hip’
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Inflammatory muscle disease
Idiopathic pain syndromes
Malignant disease (e.g. leukaemia)
Mechanical (trauma, overuse injuries, sport injuries)
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis
Inflammatory muscle disease
Idiopathic pain syndromes
Malignant disease (e.g. leukaemia, lymphoma, primary bone tumour)
The term ‘growing pains’ is a lay term often used to describe children with non-specific MSK pain and frequently perceived by parents and carers as being indicative of a benign outcome. The term is also used by health care professionals to reassure parents where there is no clear diagnosis, on the premise that, in many cases, MSK pain in children is indeed benign and self-limiting. However, anecdotally there are reports that parents of children with significant disease (such as JIA or muscle disease, or even leukaemia) will recall being told that their child had growing pains at some time before the diagnosis was made. Conversely, many GPs will refer to secondary care patients whom they often (correctly) consider to have growing pains, but will seek reassurance that serious disease is not being missed and request advice on management. Clearly uncertainty in diagnosis and management are problem areas. This article focuses on enabling GPs to make a confident diagnosis of growing pains, offers practical advice on management, and provides guidance on when to be concerned, what (if any) investigations to arrange and when to refer. In addition we provide an information sheet to give to parents or carers.
What are growing pains?
Growing pains are a clinical entity experienced by many young children with equal gender preponderance, characterised by aches and pains that are poorly localised in the lower limbs (often the calves, shins and around the ankles), and not always localised to the joint.
Parents will report that there is no obvious swelling or bruising, and the pains are often relieved with massage or simple analgesics such as paracetamol or ibuprofen. The name is actually a misnomer as there is no clear association with growth, but the idiom is embedded in medical literature, presumably as no better term has emerged; within paediatric rheumatology the current terminology is ‘benign idiopathic nocturnal limb pains of childhood’(!), which reflects our poor understanding of the aetiology (currently unknown). Irrespective of the terminology, however, the important message is that growing pains are a recognised clinical syndrome with clear parameters for making the diagnosis and guiding management. Undoubtedly growing pains give rise to significant morbidity, causing distress to the child, sleep disturbance and misery often to the whole family owing to their occurrence in the evening and at night. 5 Parents often present for medical review owing to the night-time disruption to family sleeping and concern that this is the presentation of serious disease. 5 What are the ‘rules’ of growing pains?
A diagnosis of growing pains can usually be made from the clinical assessment. Given that there is no specific test to confirm the diagnosis positively, it is important to be aware of the ‘rules’ of growing pains (Table 2), and to know that presentations outside these parameters warrant concern. It is important to probe in the history to elicit points for reassurance and alarm which are based on the potential differential diagnoses (Table 1). Key features in the history and physical examination are given in Table 3.
TABLE 2. The 'rules' of growing pains and when to be concerned.
'Rules' of growing pains
Pains never present at the start of the day after waking
Child doesn’t limp
Physical activities not limited by symptoms
Pains symmetrical in lower limbs and not limited to joints
Physical examination normal (with the exception of joint hypermobility)
Major motor milestones normal
Age range 3–12 years
Indications for concern
red flags to suggest sepsis or malignancy – fever, malaise, anorexia, weight loss, raised inflammatory markers, bone pain, persistent or worsening night pain
Abnormal growth (height and weight) Abnormal developmental milestones
Delay (especially major motor skills)
Regression of achieved motor milestones Impaired functional ability (ask about play, sport, schoolwork, ‘clumsiness’)
Limping (intermittent or persistent)
Morning symptoms (other than tiredness after disturbed sleep)
Widespread pain (such as upper limbs and back)
TABLE 3. Key questions to ask and what to look for in the examination.
HISTORY CHECK FOR
What have you noticed?
Behaviour, mood, systemic features, joint swelling, limping, bruising
What is the child like in him/herself?
Irritable, grumpy, ‘clingy’, reluctant to play, systemic features (e.g. fever, anorexia, weight loss)
Where is the pain? (ask the child to point) and what is it like?
Asymmetry, locality and pattern, pain in joints or muscles, involvement of arms, legs or other sites
How is the child in the mornings and during the day?
Diurnal variation and daytime symptoms (e.g. limping; any difficulty walking, getting dressed, toileting, or on stairs)
Has there been any
change in the child's activities?
Motor milestones (any suggestion of delay or regression of achieved milestones)
Avoidance of activities that were previously enjoyed (e.g. sport, play)
How is the child at school?
School attendance (school avoidance, bullying)
School performance (sport, schoolwork, handwriting)
Does the child wake at night with pain?
Pattern of night waking and any predictability
Can you predict when the pains may occur?
Relationship to physical activity, events at school or home and suggestion of school avoidance
What do you do when the child is in pain?
Response to analgesics; any suggestion of reinforcement of behaviour by parent
What is your main concern?
Sleep disturbance, anxiety about serious disease (arthritis, cancer), pain control
Observe the child in the room
Mood, play, chatter, mum’s interaction with the child
Screening examination of
all joints pGALS screen and evidence of hypermobility
Pallor, bruising, organomegaly, ‘unwell’, lymphadenopathy
Growth and development
Height, weight and milestones
Ask the child to jump
Evidence of muscle weakness Key features in the history
Characteristically the child with growing pains is well, with no daytime symptoms (other than fatigue after interrupted sleep) and no change in physical abilities or performance in sport, play or school. The pains are predominantly sited in the lower limbs, below the knees, and most commonly in the feet, ankles and calves;
pain in unusual sites (such as upper limbs or back) is not characteristic. Limping, whether intermittent or persistent, is not a feature of growing pains and warrants further assessment. Asymmetrical involvement is always a cause for concern: growing pains can affect one side more than the other at times, but they must involve both legs symmetrically – persistent unilateral involvement cannot be ascribed to growing pains. It must be remembered that referred pain from the hip may present with non-specific pain in the thigh or knee; the differential diagnosis of hip pathology varies with age, with Legg–Calvé–Perthes’ disease being more common in the young and slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) needing to be excluded in the older child or adolescent. Systemic features including ‘red flags’ to suggest malignancy or infection (e.g. fever, malaise, anorexia, weight loss or raised inflammatory markers) warrant urgent referral. Night waking is normally and appropriately regarded as a ‘red flag’ that necessitates exclusion of a serious underlying diagnosis (e.g. infection or malignancy). However, night waking is a common feature of growing pains and an understandable cause of anxiety among parents and health care professionals. As a general rule, the pattern of night waking in growing pains is intermittent, and often predictable after periods of activity the preceding day or evening (although this may not be immediately obvious to the parent until this is explored). Conversely, persistent night waking, especially if there are other concerns (such as unilaterality, limping, unusual location or systemic features), constitutes a ‘red flag’ and necessitates further investigation and referral. It is noteworthy that persistent night waking (typically unilateral, localised and involving the thigh), with pain relieved by non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), is a characteristic presentation for osteoid osteoma, a benign bone tumour presenting in childhood. Any suggestion of delay in major motor milestones (Table 4) excludes growing pains as a diagnosis. Pain on waking or in the daytime, symptoms suggestive of stiffness or gelling (after periods of inactivity), difficulty on stairs or getting out of a bed or chair or off the floor, or even more importantly regression of achieved milestones or functional impairment are suggestive of inflammatory joint or muscle disease (such as JIA or juvenile dermatomyositis) and always warrant prompt referral. It is therefore important to enquire about diurnal variation in symptoms and about daily activities – including play, sport and handwriting – both at home and at school. Behavioural problems in the young child may manifest as non-specific pains (headaches, tummy aches or leg pains) and sometimes sensitive questioning can reveal stressful events at home or issues concerning school, including bullying. Additionally, the parent’s reaction to the child’s complaints during the night is important to ascertain – the child being ‘rewarded’ with extra attention from the concerned parent may actually worsen the situation, and dealing with this is an important aspect of management.
TABLE 4. Major motor milestones in normal development.
Sit without support
Creep on hands and knees
Cruise when holding on to furniture and standing upright, or bottom shuffle
Climb up stairs on hands and knees
approx. 15 months
approx. 16 months
Walk down steps (non-reciprocal)
Walk up steps, alternate feet
Hop on one foot, broad jump
Skip with alternate feet
Balance on one foot for 20 seconds
6–7 years Key features in the assessment
physical assessment should include general observation of the child. This starts with watching the child coming into the consulting room, his/her mobility around the room and the interaction with the parent – the well-looking child who is chatty and happily plays with toys is much less likely to have serious underlying disease. It is important to examine the child for pallor, lymph nodes, organomegaly and the pattern of bruising – a normal pattern of bruising (i.e. different size and ages of bruises over the anterior shins) is expected in the healthy active child. When the symptoms have been present for some time, a normal growth pattern and growth rate is an indicator of good general health and the parent-held child record is useful to assess height and weight (and development). Children with growing pains often have features of hypermobility which may be generalised or localised to the hands or feet. It is not uncommon to find that children with growing pains have mobile flat feet (Figure 1), although it must be remembered that mobile flat feet are a normal variant in the young child. It is noteworthy however that not all children with hypermobility complain of pain and conversely not all children with MSK pain or growing pains are hypermobile. 6 It is important to screen all joints, as MSK symptoms may be vague, generalised or minimal, even in children with significant rheumatic disease such as JIA. The use of pGALS, a simple, quick MSK screening examination for children (paediatric Gait, Arms, Legs, Spine), is recommended and further information is available. 7 Although pGALS is validated for use in school-aged children, younger children will often co-operate in completing the screen, especially if they copy the examiner and see this as a game. It is also worth asking the child to jump – inability to do so in a child over 4 years of age suggests proximal muscle weakness and further neuromuscular assessment is warranted. 6,8
What other conditions need to be considered?
It is important to consider systemic diseases that can manifest with non-specific aches and pains (Table 1). Myalgia, arthralgia and fatigue are features of
anaemia, thyroid disease (especially hypothyroidism) and also viral infections and postviral syndromes. In the context of failure to thrive, irritability and generalised aches and pains, osteomalacia must be considered, especially with a non-Caucasian ethnic background or certain diets (e.g. vegan). JIA may present with vague symptoms of aches, rather than joint pain, and swollen joints may be subtle or easily overlooked without localising symptoms – hence the importance of screening all joints (as with the pGALS examination). Inflammatory muscle disease can be indolent and the photosensitive rash of juvenile dermatomyositis can easily be missed. Children presenting with profound, marked functional impairment with no apparent physical cause (sometimes referred to as idiopathic pain syndromes) can be differentiated from those with growing pains in that they are usually older children or adolescents, female and markedly debilitated by their pain and fatigue, with accompanying poor sleep pattern and symptoms during the day, and there is often school absenteeism. The pain can be extreme and incapacitating and affect any region (including arms, legs or back), and patients may present to clinic in a wheelchair. The child/adolescent with diffuse idiopathic pain syndrome is otherwise well and physical examination is usually normal – it is noteworthy that the characteristic tender points that are found in adults with fibromyalgia may be absent or fewer in number in children. The aetiology of idiopathic pain syndrome is unknown but affected children often have significant associated stresses in their lives, at home or at school, that may trigger or exacerbate the syndrome (e.g. parental disharmony, family bereavement, bullying or abuse) and may be high achievers (e.g. in sport or academia). Some potential stressors may only be uncovered by interviewing teachers and other family members. What investigations are required in primary care?
In the majority of cases, with a typical presentation consistent with the ‘rules’ of growing pains and without concerns elicited from the history or from the physical assessment, no further investigations are necessary. Where investigations are required, these are determined by the clinical scenario, with those most helpful listed in Table 5.
If there is clinical concern, however, then referral should not be delayed while arranging investigations in primary care and referral to general paediatrics, paediatric orthopaedics or rheumatology is appropriate, depending on local referral pathways.
TABLE 5. Investigations that may be indicated in primary care.
Full blood count (and film)
Acute phase reactants (erythrocyte sedimentation rate, C-reactive protein)
Biochemistry (bone biochemistry and vitamin D)
Growth chart (height and weight)
X-ray of legs (hips with frog views)
In most cases, a full blood count (with a blood film) and acute-phase reactants will help to exclude anaemia, infection and inflammatory conditions. Biochemistry and vitamin D, thyroid function and muscle enzymes may be indicated, and if in doubt it is worth discussing with hospital colleagues. In the young child with unilateral leg pain and limp, hip pathology must be suspected and it is important to request x-rays of both hips with ‘frog’ views to detect subtle changes which can be masked in standard views. Where the pains are generalised, physical examination unremarkable and basic tests and x-rays unhelpful, then further imaging may be contemplated and will be organised in secondary care. If there is suspicion of JIA or inflammatory muscle disease, prompt referral to paediatric rheumatology is required; this is to optimise outcome and facilitate access to eye screening for chronic anterior uveitis (a potentially blinding, often asymptomatic, complication of JIA). Investigations such as autoantibodies are not needed in primary care as they rarely help diagnosis, and uric acid assay is not necessary. The management of growing pains
Most cases can be managed in primary care and this should include explanation, reassurance and advice. The list of ‘dos and don’ts’ given in the accompanying information sheet may be helpful for parents and carers and it is very important to give the family clear instructions as to when to seek medical attention again. It is important to stress to families that in the vast majority of cases the symptoms settle with time, with no long-term sequelae, but it is equally important to be realistic and emphasise that the symptoms often fluctuate over several months and sometimes years before settling. There may be a family history of similar pains (e.g. parent and siblings) which disappeared later in childhood and this can be a source of reassurance and comfort to parents. Two Arthritis Research UK booklets may be useful:
‘Joint Hypermobility’ and ‘Growing Pains’, which is written for 5–10-year-olds and may be helpful if the child is referred for further investigations.
Parents are sometimes advised to seek orthotics for a child with flat feet and growing pains. We would caution against this approach for all children; undoubtedly there are some children who will require orthotics but, given that the mobile flat foot is a normal finding in children up to the age of 7,
in most cases the prescribing of (often expensive) orthotics is not required. Our advice is to focus on comfortable, well-fitting footwear such as training shoes, either laced (and the laces tied!) or, for the younger child, Velcro-fastened; many come with medial arch supports. ‘Prophylactic’ analgesia with paracetamol and/or ibuprofen, before bedtime and especially after busy active days when symptoms may be predicted, can help prevent night waking. During bouts of pain firm massaging may comfort the child, along with further doses of analgesia as necessary. It is important that parents or carers be advised to observe the site of apparent pain and look for physical signs (typically with growing pains there are none), and be encouraged to manage the child without undue attention, to avoid the vicious circle of ‘rewarding’ the young child with extra parental attention which may exacerbate the symptom complex. Children who are particularly hypermobile or who fail to respond to the above simple approach may benefit from a biomechanical assessment from an experienced paediatric physiotherapist, and exercises and/or orthotics may be advised. It is also important to consider alternative diagnoses and review the child for any change of features not consistent with the ‘rules’ of growing pains. 6 Summary
The child presenting with growing pains is a frequent and often distressing clinical scenario in primary care. With careful clinical assessment and knowledge and application of the ‘rules’ of growing pains, a confident diagnosis can be made in the majority of cases. Those warranting concern – usually the minority – will require investigation and possibly referral. Management in primary care requires reassurance, explanation and advice on relief (and prevention) of symptoms for the child and on how to minimise disruption to the family. Finally, it is equally important to give clear instructions to the parents or carer, with indications for review, so that significant and potentially serious disease is not overlooked.
Yeo M, Sawyer S. Chronic illness and disability. BMJ 2005;330(7493):721-3.
Jandial S, Wise E, Boyd D, Bateman B, Myers A, Foster HE. Doctors likely to encounter children with musculoskeletal complaints have low confidence in their clinical skills. J Pediatr. In press 2008.
Lanyon P, Pope D, Croft P. Rheumatology education and management skills in general practice: a national study of trainees. Ann Rheum Dis 1995;54(9):735-9.
Boyd DJ, Wise EM, Myers A, Adebajo A, Dickson J, Foster HE. Improvement in self-rated knowledge of paediatric musculoskeletal medicine in delegates attending a primary care conference. Rheumatology (Oxford) 2007;46 Suppl 1:i116(293).
Peterson HA. Leg aches. Pediatr Clin North Am 1977;24(4):731-6.
Foster HE, Jandial S. pGALS: a screening examination of the musculoskeletal system in school-aged children. Reports on the Rheumatic Diseases (Series 5), Hands On 15. Arthritis Research Campaign; 2008 June.
Foster HE, Kay LJ, Friswell M, Coady D, Myers A. Musculoskeletal screening examination (pGALS) for school-age children based on the adult GALS screen [erratum in Arthritis Rheum 2006;55(6):981]. Arthritis Rheum 2006;55(5):709-16.
pGALS – Paediatric Gait, Arms, Legs, Spine. DVD. Arthritis Research Campaign; 2006.