When it comes to osteoporosis research, there are only three
centres in the world rated higher than Sheffield University – the
University of California, Harvard and Yale in the US – so it’s in
exalted company.
Sheffield is unusual in that its clinical research spans bone
diseases from the very young to the very old, encompassing not just
osteoporosis but also the childhood form of brittle bone disease
osteogenesis imperfect and bone cancers.
Its clinical research, widely supported by Arthritis Research UK
in recent years, is underpinned by a basic biomedical research,
which has now been brought together in a single unit and involving
five departments within the medical school. The Mellanby Centre was
opened earlier this year by two former alumni of the university
renowned for their glittering careers in bone biology research UKh,
Professors Jack Martin and Graham Russell.
While the Mellanby Centre, with its labs and high-tech
equipment, will concentrate very much on basic science, Professor
Croucher, joint centre director with Professor Richard Eastell,
stresses that they want to develop new approaches to treating bone
diseases, and to translate research discoveries via the new
National Institute for Health Research-funded Biomedical Research
Unit for Bone at the Northern General Hospital in the north of the
city.
"Two of our main aims are to translate advances in research into
benefits for patients, and to promote the profile of skeletal
research in the UK," he says.
"There are many good groups of people working in many
universities, but the advantage of bringing them together under one
roof where they can talk to each other and share ideas.
"We want to bring together a lot of people with interests not
just in arthritis and bone disease, but also in children’s bone
diseases and bone cancers, and to try and learn the lesson from one
disease and apply it to another. Sheffield is very strong on the
bone cancer side and there are things we are doing in cancer
research that can be applied to osteoporosis and osteoarthritis –
there is a lot of potential for cross fertilization, and we would
hope that would be of interest to Arthritis Research UK in the
future."
Three researchers at the medical school are already receiving
funding from Arthritis Research UK in pursuing very different
research agenda. Dr Alison Gartland, lecturer in bone biology, is
now based at the Mellanby Centre, and has a new project grant to
investigate bone and cartilage loss in inflammatory arthritis.
Currently, RA therapies designed to combat inflammation in RA
aren't always effective in all patients and can have serious side
effects. These drugs typically block the inflammatory chemicals
that destroy joint tissue but at the same time also shut off the
body's ability to fight infection. New targets and treatments are
needed that utilise a more subtle approach to the problem and
understanding the detail of the molecular mechanisms involved in
inflammation should help to achieve this.
Dr Gartland explains: "We're looking at a receptor called P2X7
that's just one of hundreds of receptors present on the surface of
cells all over the body. It's present on bone and cartilage cells
and may be important in regulating the joint tissue destruction
that occurs in rheumatoid arthritis (RA).
Receptors are special responsive areas that can be activated by
chemical signals. Once activated, the cell starts to produce
molecules that affect the way the surrounding tissue works. It's a
bit like pressing a button and switching on a production line
inside the cell. In the case of P2X7, we know that it's involved in
inflammation but we don't know what it does to the actual cartilage
in a joint. We're investigating how this receptor works in healthy
joints so that we know what aspects of its activity are important
for normal function."
The P2X7 receptor also exists in different forms, or
"polymorphisms", depending on its genetic make-up. Dr Gartland and
co-workers have found that in women with the normal fully
functioning P2X7, bone loss is less severe than in women with the
polymorphic receptors.
"This suggests that the severity of disease may be linked to the
polymorphisms," she says. "If patients with polymorphisms
experience more severe bone loss, we could screen for this genetic
difference. Individuals who are positive for these polymorphisms
could then be given treatments to prevent or slow bone loss at a
much earlier stage, before irreversible damage has occurred."
The test would be part of a profile of prognostic tests to help
assess risk of disease development. Therapies are already available
to inhibit these receptors and this test may be useful to predict
which patients will and won't respond well to therapy, and direct
treatment accordingly.
As well as aiding prognosis and disease management strategies,
the results of this research should benefit other musculoskeletal
diseases such as osteoporosis and osteoarthritis.
The development of anti-TNF drugs represents a considerable
breakthrough in terms of arthritis therapy. Tumour necrosis factor,
or TNF, is an inflammatory chemical that's normally produced to
protect the healthy body against infection. However, in RA, TNF
production is continuous, and chronic pain, swelling, and
eventually joint damage results.
Epigenetics (meaning "over" or "above" genetics) is a rapidly
advancing area of research that is changing the way we understand
disease processes. We may be born with a set of genes that
programme our bodies but the activity of these genes is influenced
by epigenetic factors.
These factors often work as simple on/off switch mechanisms: all
our cells carry the same genes but only specific ones are "active"
or expressed where they are needed. Pancreatic cells, for example,
produce insulin but kidney cells don't. The insulin producing genes
are switched on in the pancreas but switched off in the kidney.
Professor Wilson comments: "Epigenetics play an important role
in the development of human disease, including arthritis and
cancer. In RA it may influence how severe the disease is and how
patients respond to treatment. But the system is very complex -
there are hundreds of thousands of epigenetic variations that
switch genes on and off in different combinations. If we can find
out how epigenetics affects the production of chemicals like TNF we
might be able to devise new therapies to regulate this, and dampen
down the aggressive nature of the disease."
Epigenetic markers can be measured and by comparing them in
healthy individuals and individuals with RA, the ones responsible
for different effects, like the overproduction of inflammatory
chemicals, can be identified.
"We've already found a small difference in one of these markers
that is linked to the production of IL-6, a major inflammatory
molecule," says Professor Wilson, "and increased epigenetic markers
are associated with higher TNF production."
The epigenetic marks on the TNF gene change with age as does the
risk of developing RA. Could this marker be a predictor for RA risk
or severity? If so, this could be a very useful clinical test to
help disease prognosis, guide treatment, and predict treatment
outcomes.
Tendons are tough, flexible pieces of tissue that attach muscle
to joints and convert muscle force into skeletal movement. Damaged
tendons lose their stretch and flexibility, causing considerable
pain and immobility. The healing process is difficult and lengthy
because the underlying tendon fibres don't always repair properly
and patient quality of life is reduced.
Research aimed at improving tendon repair is difficult because
studies rely on cell cultures grown in laboratory conditions and
these don't model the real life situation very well. However, a
revolutionary new research tool is about to change the way that we
view tendon repair.
Dr Dawn Walker, Research Councils UK Fellow and lecturer in the
Department of Computer Science, is attempting to create a "virtual
tendon" using sophisticated computer simulation technology, with
funding from an Arthritis Research UK project grant.
Dr Walker, a physicist by training, has extensive experience in
the application of computer simulation technology to living tissue
systems. She has successfully developed models for other tissue
types and will adapt some of the software from these projects for
use in the current project.
"Tendon isn't the most popular tissue to research" she says. "In
the media, the heart or brain are much more interesting areas of
development. The "virtual heart" project hit the headlines some
years ago and is now proving to be an extremely valuable model for
cardiac research projects. However, tendon problems are very common
and cause immense suffering - we really need to address this
disease area and improve predictive outcomes and treatment
methods."
The project combines established knowledge of tendon structure
and tissue dynamics with information from current laboratory
research projects studying the effects of damage and repair in
living tendon cells.
"All the data is integrated into the programme", says Dr Walker.
"We know how tendon is constructed in healthy tissue and what
happens to it when it's subjected to the stresses and strains of
exercise, overwork and injury. It's important that we develop the
model by testing it at every stage against real laboratory data to
be sure that our model mimics the real life situation and is
relevant to patient outcomes."
Once the model is up and running, any combination of parameters
can be altered to represent different patient types and tissue
damage, and the outcomes assessed. Eventually, the project aims to
use the virtual tendon to inform therapy options and assess
outcomes.